Mutual fund churning is the routine buying and selling of mutual fund units to take advantage of short-term market cycles. This approach is quite common with investors or financial advisors and is used primarily to improve returns by recalibrating the portfolio in response to changing market conditions. Yet mutual fund churning can also result in higher costs and tax effects that lower long-term profit opportunities. In this article, we’ll understand what is mutual fund churning, how to do mutual fund churning, the best times to consider churning, its effects on investors and the costs associated with it.

Mutual fund churning occurs when an investor repeatedly buys and sells mutual fund units. This approach is generally employed to capitalise on market imbalances in the short term and respond to evolving economic conditions or changes in investor objectives and risk tolerance by rebalancing a portfolio. Mutual fund churning, hence, may result in some quick money for investors. But it also brings with it risks and costs such as transaction fees, exit loads and extra taxes that might decrease the overall returns. Investors should be aware of mutual fund churning meaning to come up with an idea for their investment plans.

There can be multiple reasons for mutual fund churning like market volatility, change in economic conditions and possibly investor shift in financial goals or sometimes a recommendation from financial advisors. But for an investor, it is essential to differentiate between strategic portfolio rebalancing and excessive trading as this may not always be in the interest of the investor. Too much mutual fund churning increases the costs and tax liabilities, which can dilute the efficacy of investment strategies.

Those who want to churn their mutual fund portfolio promptly, need to do so systematically by re-evaluating the investment objectives, seeing what investments they have in place, identifying which funds should be bought, completing an exit plan and finally implementing that strategy. It is important for investors to keep in mind their financial objectives and risk tolerance at each step of the churn as there are also costs associated with every trade.

Re-evaluate your investment objectives

To churn your mutual fund portfolio, the first thing you need to do is reassess investment goals. It includes evaluating your financial objectives, risk appetite and investment horizon. Investors should consider whether their current portfolio is in line with where they are now and if things have changed from a financial perspective such that the strategy needs to be updated. Regularly reassessing you aims will also make sure that your portfolio is consistent with whatever it is in the long term.

Assess your existing investments

When you know what your investment goal is, the next step would be to evaluate all of your current investments. This includes evaluating every last one of your mutual funds based on performance, considering predefined measures like returns, risk levels, and expense ratios as well as, how much the mutual fund is fulfilling its objectives. Identify funds that are underperforming or simply not fitting within your investment strategy.

Pick out new mutual funds

Once you have identified your portfolio funds, the next step is to select new mutual fund schemes based on different goals. In financial terms, this means seeking funds that have established track records of performance and risk ratings compatible with your investment philosophy at a reasonable expense. Investing across a range of asset classes, in other words, diversifying can reduce risk and improve returns as well. Working with a financial advisor could help you identify what the best course of action would be according to your new plan.

Establish your exit plan

If you are considering the churning approach, then make sure there exists a proper exit plan. It includes deciding when and how to sell your mutual fund units, based on market conditions as well as, tax laws and transaction charges. A successful exit strategy will also reduce losses and increase gains, ensuring the churn is in sync with your financial goals.

Execute the strategy

In the end, implement a churning strategy by selling those mutual fund units and buying new ones. Closely monitoring the market ensures we get the best possible prices for these transactions. Monitor transaction costs, taxes and other expenses related to the trades. Periodically review your portfolio to guarantee it is consistent with investment goals and risk tolerance.

Mutual fund churning should not be a common practice but more of an action taken based on certain circumstantial reasons. Churning is an important factor that drives high return and cost reduction. Cases when churning should be done are:

Shift in market conditions

A change in market conditions -- like interest rates, inflation or an economic forecast -- might encourage you to analyse your mutual fund holdings. However, if your existing holdings are ill-positioned for the new market environment, churning may be required in order to reorient your investments around prevailing trends.

Change in mutual fund asset allocation

A mutual fund that changes its asset allocation strategy is another situation in which churning might be required. The risk profile and the potential return of a fund can shift when a fund manager moves toward or away from stocks, bonds or any other asset class in anticipation of changing market conditions. Now if these changes do not go well with your investment objectives you might want to consider churning out our portfolio.

Mutual fund performance

In a market downturn, if one or more mutual funds in your portfolio underperform relative to their peers and benchmarks it might be a reason to churn. If the fund keeps lagging behind its benchmark or peers it should be replaced by a superior-performing one. Regularly check the performance of your mutual funds to ensure that you meet many of these financial goals.

Material changes in fund management

Churning can also be the result of major changes in fund management as a whole—for example, if a star fund manager leaves or there is a change to the governing investment philosophy. The performance of a mutual fund frequently depends on the skill and strategy of its management team. If key moves or takeovers happen, reevaluate whether the fund still meets your portfolio criteria.

The impact of mutual fund churning can be bifurcated into multiple aspects, both in favour and against the investors. Undoubtedly, this practice can realise higher returns and adapt strategies as market conditions shift but it has its issues. The costs involved in churning are higher transaction charges, exit loads and taxes, which may erode your returns too regularly. In fact, too much churning could lead to short-term capital gains that are taxed more heavily than long-term ones and so eat into net returns further.

Moreover, compounding is a long-term process and if you are trading frequently then that may disrupt the process. Investments grow best over long periods of time, and compounding works best when it is uninterrupted. Churning also can lead to overtrading, where investors make decisions based on short-term market movements rather than remaining committed to a long-term strategy. Behaviour like this may lead to taking more risks or making a bad investment decision and hence can reduce overall portfolio performance.

Churning done after careful consideration can help the investors to seize market opportunities at the right times and rebalance their portfolios well as guard against risks. Investors should consider the advantages and disadvantages of mutual fund churning and only pursue trading activity that is consistent with their long-term investment plan and financial goals.

There are many costs associated with churning mutual funds, however, the aggregate of these may decrease the efficacy of this strategy. Understanding these charges is important when investors intend to churn as a part of their investment strategy.

Exit load

Exit load is charged by mutual funds when an investor redeems his units before a specified period. This fee is supposed to discourage frequent trading and also protect long-term investors’ interests. This exit load may differ according to the fund you have chosen and how long your investment was. Exiting with high exit loads leads to erosion of funds and can greatly reduce the amount churned, if not sold at a longer interval since purchase.

Bid-ask spread

The bid-ask spread is the difference between the price at which you can buy (bid) and sell (ask) mutual fund units. Additional costs to investors arise since frequent churning increases a stock's bid-ask spread, particularly in volatile markets. The wider the spread, the higher the churning costs.

Expense ratios

These are the annual fees that mutual funds charge to operate and cover administrative expenses. These could lead to churning in holding multiple mutual funds with different expense ratios. New funds, particularly if they have higher expense ratios than the existing investments, could raise costs for managing the portfolio and limit returns.

Taxes

Taxes can be a huge expense when investors churn mutual funds. If you buy and sell frequently, it can lead to a short-term capital gain/loss, which is taxed at a much higher rate than long-term gains. Moreover, churning can cause taxable events where there would otherwise be none if the investments were simply held longer. Investors need to understand the taxation effects of churning so they can maximise their after-tax returns.

Whether mutual fund churning is a wise choice or truly beneficial over the long term comes down to an investor's approach, based on risk tolerance and financial objectives. For some, a little bit of churning now and then may help with value accretion, risk management or market opportunity utilization. But, at the same time, executing trades on a regular basis can increase costs/taxes and potential underperformance caused by excessive trading. This is a better approach for many long-term investors than the frequent churning that chasing momentum would likely require. Churning makes it more difficult to reach your goals; some care should be taken when considering churning. Investors should weigh the risks/costs/benefits of any activity that strays from long-term intent.

Mutual fund churning is a practice that involves frequently buying and selling mutual fund units with the aim of exploiting market opportunities or adapting to changing conditions. While it can provide a short-term benefit, its costs and risks may not be appropriate for all investors. One must consider the pros and cons, before adopting a strategy of mutual fund churning.

To cater to the needs of an individual, who seeks personalised investment advice and tools required for effective portfolio management, platforms like Bajaj Finserv have foolproof answers which help them in achieving their financial goals. Based on your financial goals, you can choose from a plethora of mutual fund schemes and use their resources that make investing in mutual funds easy and hassle-free.