The EV EBIT ratio is a widely used financial metric that offers several advantages for investors, but it also has some limitations that should be considered when making investment decisions. Both of these are discussed as follows:
Advantages
Holistic valuation: The EV EBIT ratio is a holistic measure that considers both equity and debt, offering a comprehensive view of an organisation’s total worth. While the Price to Earnings ratio considers only equity, the EV/EBIT ratio includes the debt that the company carries in the valuation. Particularly in sectors that carry huge debt, like utilities or infrastructure, this aspect becomes very important. For example, an company like NTPC, which has substantial debt due to its capital-intensive nature, would be more accurately valued using the EV/EBIT ratio.
Cross-sector comparison: One of the major strengths of EV/EBIT is that it would normalize the differences across industries, hence making it quite easy to compare companies across different sectors. For example, using the EV/EBIT ratio in India would better compare a manufacturing giant like Tata Steel with a tech company like Infosys, since this would adjust for the two different capital structures of these industries. It allows investors to determine more appropriately the relative value of various companies across sectors.
Operational focus: The EV EBIT ratio focuses on the core business performance of a company by filtering out non-operating factors like taxation and interest. Since this focuses on the operational earnings, EBIT gives a clearer picture of how well a company is doing with regard to primary business activities. For example, if a firm like Reliance Industries has high earnings but also high interest expenses, then the EV/EBIT ratio would reflect its operational efficiency, which is quite independent of its financial structure.
Limitations
Industry variability: The EV EBIT ratio might be less useful when comparing companies across different industries that have very different financial structures. For instance, while considering a fast-growing technology company against a capital-intensive manufacturing business, it really does not make much sense if the industry norms are not kept in consideration. On the other hand, the ratio might show an increased EV/EBIT for a technology company with some growth prospects, while it would indicate stability and lesser risk for a manufacturing company.
Exclusion of non-operating income: EV EBIT ratio excludes all other sources of income which lie outside the core operations, as in the case of investment and non-operating income, which can be significant for some companies. This exclusion might lead to an incomplete assessment of a company’s overall financial health. For example, Infosys Company would generate a good amount of non-operating income from its investments, which would not be reflected in the EV/EBIT ratio, undervaluing the company's true earnings potential.
Susceptibility to market conditions: The EV EBIT ratio can be affected by volatile market conditions, which can skew the ratio and impact its reliability as a standalone valuation tool. For instance, the stock prices swing wildly around during economic uncertainty, changing the EV component of the ratio enormously at this time. It is then very hard to accurately use the EV/EBIT ratio as an isolated measure for a company's value. As such, investors should use this metric with caution alone in turbulent markets.
Also read: What is an expense ratio