Though capital gains distributions are beneficial, they are not without their concerns. One of the biggest downsides is a potential tax liability. As previously mentioned, these distributions are taxable and in some cases, they can bump an investor into a higher tax bracket, resulting in a higher tax amount. Since short-term capital gains are taxed at a higher rate than long-term, this is especially true for short-term capital gains.
Additionally, capital gains distributions may be difficult to predict as they can only occur once the fund sells securities. Since dividends are typically paid on a regular, predictable basis, quarterly or monthly, the amount of capital gains a mutual fund will distribute can vary widely from year to year. The result of this is an environment where planning finances, particularly around a fluctuating income source can be challenging without managing cash flow effectively.
Moreover, capital gains distributions could lower the net asset value (NAV) of a mutual fund. When a fund distributes its profits to shareholders, the NAV goes down by the distribution amount. If the fund’s performance is not commensurate with the reduction of the value of the base investment, it is easy to see how this can be quite problematic.
Capital gains distributions may be less beneficial to investors holding mutual funds in taxable accounts as opposed to those who hold the funds in tax-advantaged accounts. For example, in a normal taxable account, taxes have to be paid on the distribution received even if an investor is to reinvest it. Over time, this can eat into overall returns. On the other hand, for tax-advantaged accounts, such as IRAs or 401(k)s, distributions can be reinvested without immediate tax liabilities.
Lastly, capital gains distributions can be a detriment to investors who seek low volatility and focus on capital preservation. If investments are a source of income, receiving the distribution could mean having to part with shares or even erode the principal investment, which might negatively affect long-term financial goals.