Holding Period Return

The Holding Period Return (HPR) represents the overall return on an asset or investment portfolio during the time it has been held. The return generated from a holding period can be realised if the investment or asset is held for a period. If you are an investor, then learning about the return from a holding period of an investment or asset becomes imperative for you to make the most of your returns. Let us delve into the subject further.

What is the holding period return?

The Holding Period Return (HPR) refers to the complete return on an asset or investment portfolio over the duration it has been held. It measures the total change in value, including both capital gains or losses and income received, such as dividends or interest, during the holding period. This return can either be realized if the asset or portfolio has already been held for the specified time or projected if an investor plans to purchase the asset in the future. The HPR provides valuable insights for assessing the performance of investments over a set period, helping investors compare different assets or portfolios to make informed decisions.

The holding period return (HPR) is sometimes referred to as the Holding Period Yield (HPY). As an investor, the holding period return holds importance for you as it permits you to evaluate the performance of your investments during a period.

Example of holding period return

Holding period return meaning can be best understood with the help of the example below:

Let us say that a person invested Rs. 10,000 in the shares of Company X three years ago. Each year, the company has managed to distribute dividends to its investors (its shareholders). Each year, the investor receives Rs. 100 as the dividend amount. So far, the investor (in 3 years) has earned Rs. 300 as their total income from dividends. Today, the investor sold their company shares for Rs. 12,000. Now, the investor wishes to know the holding period return of their investment. If you use the following formula, you know the holding period return in terms of a percentage:

Holding Period Return = (Income + End of Period Value of Investment - Initial Value of Investment) / Initial Value of Investment

Therefore, with the amounts in the example, Holding Period Return = (Rs. 300 + Rs. 12,000 - Rs. 10,000) / Rs. 10,000 = 0.23 or 23%

Therefore, the investor’s investment in Company X shares earned 23% for the whole period of the investor’s holding of the investment.

Formula for holding period return

When you ask the question, “What is holding period return?”, you may be able to get a response if you know the formula to obtain the holding period return on an investment. Of course, there are many calculators available online to calculate your returns on any investment you make, including investment in mutual funds. By using a mutual fund calculator, you can easily estimate your returns from a mutual fund investment. Nonetheless, it is important to know the formula for calculating the holding period return as this helps you to apply it to different investments, including mutual funds. The formula is mentioned below:

Holding Period Return = (Income + End of Period Value of Investment - Initial Value of Investment) / Initial Value of Investment

How to calculate the holding period return?

The holding period return meaning becomes clear to understand if you know how to calculate the holding period return. Nowadays, you get a plethora of online calculators that aid you in estimating your returns from any investment, be it in stocks or mutual fund units. In case you wish to calculate the holding period return on an online calculator, all you need to do is to enter some values like the initial value of your investment, and the final value (this may be an estimation), the date of buying the investment and the date of selling the investment. After this, you can click on the “Calculate” button and get your estimated response.

The holding period return can also be calculated by using a mathematical formula, and this has been highlighted in previous sections.

Calculation of holding period return

An example of holding period return that helps you to compare two mutual funds may be useful in grasping the concept of holding period return:

Let us say that you have invested in two different mutual fund schemes. Now you want to find out which investment performed better, Mutual Fund ABC in force for 3 years and going from Rs. 1000 to Rs. 1500, providing Rs. 100 in distributions, or Mutual Fund XYZ, starting at Rs. 2000 and appreciating to Rs. 2300, generating Rs. 150 in distributions during a 3-year period?

Fund ABC = (100 + 1500 – 1000) / 1000 = 60%

Holding Period Return = 60%

Fund XYZ = (150 + 2300 – 2000) / 2000 = 22.5%

Holding Period Return = 22.5%

Clearly, Fund ABC has performed better than Fund XYZ. Considering that these funds were held for the same periods, although the invested sum is more in Fund XYZ, the holding period return is less than that of Fund ABC.

Importance of holding period return for investors

Learning about the holding period return meaning is the key for investors to make informed investment decisions. The holding period return gives you a potentially prospective idea about two different investment instruments, aiding you to make educated comparisons aligned with your financial preferences and goals.

A fundamental tool in investment management, the holding period return is a metric that gives you a comprehensive perspective about investments and assets as it considers the capital appreciation of the investment or asset and the distributions of income associated with the asset or investment (such as dividends or bonus payments). Furthermore, the holding period return metric is employed to identify the tax rate that is applicable to any asset or investment that yields returns.

Applications of Holding Period Return (HPR)

The Holding Period Return (HPR) serves as a versatile metric for evaluating investment performance, managing portfolios, assessing risks, and comparing investment opportunities. It provides investors with a comprehensive understanding of returns over specific periods, enabling more informed financial decisions.

1. Investment analysis: The Holding Period Return (HPR) is a valuable tool for analysing the performance of individual investments over a defined period. It provides a clear indicator of the returns generated, encompassing both capital gains and income such as dividends or interest, offering investors insight into their investment outcomes.
2. Portfolio management: HPR plays an integral role in managing investment portfolios. It helps investors and portfolio managers assess the total returns generated by different assets, enabling them to monitor performance and make adjustments to optimize portfolio returns effectively.
3. Risk assessment: HPR is instrumental in evaluating investment risk by highlighting the volatility and potential returns associated with various assets. By comparing the HPR of multiple investments, investors can better understand the risk-return balance and refine their strategies accordingly.
4. Comparative analysis: HPR serves as a useful metric for comparing the performance of diverse investment options. By calculating the HPR for different assets, investors can identify those that deliver the best returns relative to their initial investments, aiding in better decision-making.
5. Performance evaluation: The HPR is widely used for evaluating the effectiveness of investment strategies and decisions. It allows investors and analysts to assess whether their choices have been profitable and gauge the success of their strategies over specific time frames.

Advantages of holding period return

HPR offers a simple, clear, and effective way to evaluate investment performance, compare different assets, and make informed decisions. It helps investors assess total returns, manage portfolios, and understand risk, providing valuable insights into investment strategies.

1. Ease of use: The Holding Period Return (HPR) is simple to calculate, making it an accessible tool for investors and analysts to assess investment performance.
2. Clarity: HPR offers a transparent measure of the total return from an investment over a specific period, incorporating both capital gains and income such as interest or dividends.
3. Comparison: It provides a standardised metric for comparing the performance of different investments or portfolios within the same time frame.
4. Performance assessment: HPR enables investors to evaluate the success of their investment decisions and strategies by measuring actual returns.
5. Informed decision-making: By understanding HPR, investors can make better decisions about buying, holding, or selling investments based on profitability and performance.
6. Portfolio management: HPR is a critical tool for portfolio managers, helping them monitor performance and make adjustments to asset allocations to maximise returns.
7. Risk analysis: It assists in evaluating the risk-return balance by highlighting the volatility and potential returns of various assets.
8. Historical performance tracking: HPR facilitates historical analysis, allowing investors to measure returns across different periods to identify trends and investment patterns.
9. Benchmarking: Investors can use HPR as a benchmark to compare investment performance against specific standards or indices, offering a basis for evaluating relative success.
10. Comprehensive measurement: HPR captures the total return on an investment, combining both capital gains and income, giving a complete picture of investment profitability.

Factors affecting holding period return

Several factors can impact the Holding Period Return (HPR) of an investment:

1. Market conditions: The broader market environment, such as whether the market is experiencing a bull or bear trend, plays a significant role in asset price movements. In a bull market, asset prices generally rise, while in a bear market, they tend to fall, thus influencing the HPR accordingly.
2. Interest rates: Fluctuations in interest rates can affect the yields on interest-sensitive investments like bonds. Higher interest rates typically result in lower bond prices, which can reduce the total return from these investments and impact the HPR.
3. Economic factors: Macroeconomic elements, including GDP growth, inflation, and employment levels, can influence the performance of investments. A strong economy usually results in better corporate earnings and higher stock prices, which positively impact HPR.
4. Company performance: The financial health and success of individual companies in which investments are made can directly affect the HPR. Strong earnings, consistent dividends, and robust business operations can lead to higher returns on investments.
5. Sector and industry trends: Investments focused on particular sectors or industries can be more vulnerable to sector-specific risks and trends. Changes in regulations, consumer preferences, or technological innovations within an industry can significantly influence HPR.

Limitations of using HPR

HPR has limitations, including time frame dependency, inflation impact, and exclusion of transaction costs, which can affect its accuracy. Below are the limitations of using HPR:

• Time frame dependency: HPR measures returns over a specific holding period, which may not fully reflect the long-term performance of an investment. Short-term price fluctuations can distort the accuracy of the HPR calculation.
• Impact of inflation: HPR does not account for inflation, meaning it does not offer a real return after considering the effects of inflation. This limitation can lead to an overestimation of the true purchasing power of investment returns over time.
• External economic factors: Economic variables such as interest rate changes, inflation, and geopolitical events can influence asset prices and returns, affecting the reliability of HPR calculations.
• Dividend and income timing: HPR assumes that any dividends or income generated from investments are reinvested at the same rate of return, which may not always be feasible or accurate in practice.
• Transaction costs: HPR does not consider transaction-related expenses like brokerage fees, taxes, or other costs incurred when buying or selling investments. These costs can lower the overall return, impacting the accuracy of HPR.

Difference between HPR and total return

The Holding Period Return (HPR) measures the return on an investment over a specific period, considering only the capital gains and income earned during that time frame. It provides a snapshot of how the asset or investment performed within the duration it was held.

In contrast, Total Return takes a broader view by incorporating not only the HPR but also any income that has been reinvested during the investment period. This includes dividends, interest, and other forms of income, as well as any changes in the market value of the asset over multiple periods. Total Return offers a more comprehensive measure of an investment's performance by accounting for all sources of return, both realised and reinvested, over time.

Key takeaways

• Holding period return, or holding period yield is the total amount of return that an investment earns in the duration that it has been held by the investor.
• The period that an investor holds an investment is known as the holding period. In terms of a security, the holding period is the duration between the buying and selling of a security. Related to mutual fund schemes, the holding period may be considered the time from which you buy mutual fund units to the time you exit the fund.
• Holding period return is a useful tool to make similar comparisons between investment returns bought at different times.

Conclusion

There are several metrics in the investment ecosystem that help you to select investment instruments according to your unique requirements and financial goals. The holding period return amounts to the total return that you receive from the holding of an investment or an asset. Usually expressed as a percentage, the holding period return gives you a clue about returns you may expect from one or more investments, taking the holding period into consideration.

Investing is not a complicated process and if you start early, there are potentially lucrative opportunities for you to invest and earn potentially prospective returns. With myriad options in terms of investment channels and instruments on offer, mutual fund schemes are a popular choice among investors today as they can be tailored to investors’ specific needs. If you wish to explore the world of mutual funds, and know about the different types available, you can visit the engaging Bajaj Finserv Mutual Fund Platform. Make your way through easy mutual fund investment as you compare more than 1000 mutual fund schemes with convenient online calculators to help you make smart decisions.

Essential tools for all mutual fund investors