How do windfall taxes work?
Windfall taxes generally apply to well-established businesses that are more likely to reap gains from external circumstances. Comparatively, IPO investors may still be protected from the impact of such taxes as their funds are allocated to an emerging stock.
One example of an unprecedented situation is the Russia-Ukraine crisis, which resulted in a surge in crude oil prices. This global event proved advantageous for several oil and gas sectors, leading to spikes in their profits and prompting the government to levy a windfall tax on these industries. As mentioned earlier, the tax here is not connected to the company’s production practices or intentionally devised strategies and is purely based on a singular incident. It is essential to remember that windfall taxes are applied in addition to the standard tax rate. Typically, these taxes are associated with securities that exhibit high volatility levels.
The main purpose behind imposing windfall tax is to seize a part of unanticipated gains of a business or industry. Such a measure promotes a fair distribution of profits within society instead of solely benefiting a small number of individuals. Besides being a means for redistribution, windfall taxes also prevent companies from seeking ways to exploit such sudden gains in the future.
When did India introduce a windfall tax?
On 1st July 2022, the Indian government introduced a special additional excise duty on petrol, diesel, and aviation turbine fuel (ATF) exports. This move was aimed at ensuring adequate domestic supply and curbing excessive profits for refiners.
Prior to this, Indian refiners, such as Reliance and Nayara Energy, were prioritizing exports due to higher international prices. This led to a shortage of fuel in the domestic market and higher prices for consumers.
By imposing the excise duty, the government incentivized refiners to sell their products domestically. This benefited domestic oil marketing companies (OMCs) like HPCL and BPCL, allowing them to purchase fuel at a lower cost and pass on the savings to consumers.
The government later reduced the excise duty on petrol and ATF, while maintaining a lower tax on diesel. This decision aimed to boost investor confidence in the oil refining sector, as exemplified by the rise in Vedanta Ltd's stock price.
However, in October 2022, the government reintroduced a special additional excise duty on ATF and increased the duty on diesel in response to rising global oil prices caused by OPEC's production cuts.
The government continues to review the quantum of the windfall tax every fortnight to adjust to changing market conditions.
Who is obligated to pay windfall taxes?
Windfall taxes are imposed on businesses and industries that attain excessive profits during unanticipated situations. Pandemics, wars, shortages, and changes in state policies are a few examples of unprecedented external conditions. More specifically, windfall taxes are levied on industries like oil, gas, and mining as they commonly earn disproportionate gains from resources owned collectively by society.
In certain nations, the telecommunications sectors might also be charged with windfall taxes. This situation usually arises when the industry is bestowed with exclusive licences that generate high profits. The Indian government also levies windfall taxes on individuals who have made gains via inheritances and lotteries.
Why are countries levying windfall taxes now?
Since late last year, there has been a significant surge in the prices of petrol, crude oil, gas, and coal. This increase has been compounded by factors such as the COVID-19 pandemic and the ongoing Russia-Ukraine conflict and subsequent sanctions. As a result, energy companies have benefited from substantial profits at the expense of consumers who have faced higher energy costs.
In response to this situation, the UN Secretary-General has called on countries to impose windfall taxes on these companies. This would help to mitigate the impact of rising energy prices on consumers. Several countries, including the UK and Germany, are now considering implementing such taxes.
What are the advantages of windfall taxes?
- The primary benefit of the windfall tax system is an increased income for the government. This extra revenue can be employed to counterbalance losses from fiscal downturns and encourage investment in public welfare projects.
- Windfall taxes ensure a fair distribution of profits stemming from extraordinary circumstances, enabling stable economic growth that strengthens the overall well-being of the country in the long run.
- Such tax systems also help in the regulation and stabilisation of prices by controlling excessive gains. Consequently, consumers may also benefit from windfall taxes through the lowered prices of scarce commodities.
What are the disadvantages of windfall taxes?
- Windfall taxes are majorly disadvantageous to companies as they reduce profits.
- Heavy taxes could also curb innovation as companies may be forced to limit their investment in research and development efforts.
- Industries or companies might transfer the burden of windfall taxes to consumers to sustain their profit margins, ultimately spiking market costs for consumers.
- Windfall taxes may also drive away investors, which could diminish investments in a particular sector. This could possibly stall the overall economic growth.
What are the issues with imposing windfall taxes?
Here are the issus with imposing windfall taxes-
- Creates uncertainty – Investments increase when the regulatory environment is stable and inspires business confidence. However, if the taxes keep getting imposed and withdrawn, then producers are unsure of their investments.
- Lack of definition – It is hard to give an objective rationale on how much to tax, on what extent of excess income to impose the tax upon, which sectors to tax etc. Hence, it may create discontent among companies, especially smaller companies who could not charge as high an amount during supply shortages, who think that the tax is unfair. Moreover, not all companies may understand the windfall tax definition and may think that it is a tax that is here to stay or it is going to be imposed from time to time for any small increase in the firm’s individual profits.
Closing thoughts
Windfall taxes are mandated by the government for companies and industries that realise above-average profits due to unprecedented events such as pandemics, wars, or changes in official state policies. Usually, they are levied on sectors like oil, gas, and mining, which are likely to benefit from unforeseen events. Windfall tax systems help the government achieve additional revenue, which is invested in the development of public infrastructure. Likewise, they curb companies from taking unfair advantage of such unanticipated gains. However, they could also discourage investment in technological innovation and repel investors from committing funds to a particular sector, hindering economic progress.
Read our interested articles:
What is deferred tax?
What is a tax haven?
What is the securities transaction tax?
How gains from intraday trading are taxed
