Mutual Funds vs PMS

Mutual funds (MF) generally have lower fees compared to Portfolio Management Service (PMS). They usually charge expense ratios covering management and operational costs, while PMS tends to have higher management fees and often includes performance fees tied to returns. While both MF and PMS provide opportunities for wealth growth and diversification, comprehending their variances is essential for investors. In this article, we explore the disparities between Mutual Funds and PMS, analysing their fee structures, investment approaches, regulatory environments, and suitability for diverse investment goals. While mutual funds offer a low entry point of Rs. 500, portfolio management services require a minimum investment of approximately Rs. 25 lakh, making them less accessible to the general public. By evaluating these factors, investors can make educated decisions aligned with their financial objectives and risk tolerance.

What are mutual funds?

Mutual funds are a collective investment option that pool money from many investors and invest it in a diversified portfolio of securities, such as stocks, bonds, gold, etc. A mutual fund is managed by a professional fund manager who follows a predefined investment objective and strategy. A mutual fund charges an expense ratio for its management and operational costs. A mutual fund offers various schemes to suit different investor needs, such as equity, debt, hybrid, etc. Read more about, What is mutual fund.

What is an index mutual fund?

An index fund is a type of mutual fund that invests in a basket of securities that track a specific market index, such as the Nifty 50 or the Sensex. An index fund aims to replicate the performance of the index by holding the same stocks in the same proportion as the index. An index fund is a passive investment option that offers low-cost, diversified, and transparent exposure to the market. Read more about, What are index funds.

What are portfolio management services?

Portfolio management services are a customised investment option that offer tailor-made solutions to high net worth individuals (HNIs) or institutional investors. A portfolio manager manages the portfolio of the client according to their risk profile, investment objectives, and preferences. A portfolio manager has the discretion to buy and sell securities on behalf of the client, without seeking their approval for each transaction. A portfolio manager charges a fee for their services, which can be fixed, variable, or performance-based.

Differences between mutual funds and portfolio management services

Mutual funds and portfolio management services differ on various aspects, such as:

In India, equity investment avenues include Mutual Funds and Portfolio Management Service (PMS). While both PMS and Mutual Funds involve investing in similar stocks, their execution and management styles vary, as do their portfolio construction approaches. Mutual funds and portfolio management services differ on various aspects, such as:

• Portfolio size: PMS requires a minimum investment of Rs. 50 lakh, whereas mutual funds can be started with as low as Rs. 500. PMS is suitable for HNIs who have large investible surplus, whereas mutual funds are suitable for all types of investors.
• Flexibility: PMS offers more flexibility and customisation to the client, as the portfolio manager can design the portfolio according to the client’s needs and preferences. Mutual funds offer less flexibility and customisation, as the fund manager follows a predefined investment objective and strategy for all the investors in the scheme.
• Accounts: PMS offers individual accounts to each client, where the client owns the securities in their name. Mutual funds offer pooled accounts to all the investors in the scheme, where the investors own units of the scheme and not the underlying securities.
• Value: PMS offers the current market value of the portfolio to the client, which can vary depending on the market conditions. Mutual funds offer the net asset value (NAV) of the scheme to the investors, which is calculated at the end of each business day based on the closing prices of the securities.
• Transparency: PMS offers more transparency to the client, as the portfolio manager provides regular reports and updates on the portfolio performance, holdings, transactions, etc. Mutual funds offer less transparency to the investors, as the fund manager only discloses the portfolio holdings and performance on periodic basis.
• Minimum investment: The minimum investment threshold for Portfolio Management Services (PMS) significantly exceeds that of mutual funds. While mutual funds allow for initial investments as low as Rs. 500, PMS typically require a minimum investment of Rs. 50 lakhs. This substantial entry barrier serves as a safeguard, ensuring that only investors with a high tolerance for risk and the financial capacity to absorb potential losses consider PMS.
• Risk profile: PMS is inherently a high-risk, high-reward investment avenue. The personalized nature of PMS, managed by a dedicated portfolio manager, introduces unique considerations. The manager's individual biases and investment philosophy are likely to influence the portfolio's composition. However, the active management of PMS can potentially yield substantial returns.
• Regulatory oversight: Mutual funds are subject to stringent oversight and regulation by the Securities Exchange Board of India (SEBI). In contrast, PMS, being private arrangements between investors and portfolio managers, are exempt from certain regulatory disclosures. This lack of public scrutiny may present potential risks.
• Fees and charges: The personalised nature of PMS typically translates into higher fees compared to mutual funds. PMS investors may incur charges for accounting, custody, brokerage, exit load, performance-based fees, and management fees.

PMS vs mutual funds - Key differences in a comparison table

Here are some details to help you choose between Mutual Funds and PMS:

Types of PMS

There are two types of PMS in India:

• Discretionary PMS: In this type, the portfolio manager has the full authority to make investment decisions on behalf of the client. The client has no say in the selection or timing of the securities in the portfolio.
• Non-discretionary PMS: In this type, the portfolio manager only advises the client on the investment strategy and the securities to invest in. The client has the final say in the execution of the transactions.

Types of mutual funds

There are many types of mutual funds in India, but some of the common ones are:

• Equity funds: These funds invest predominantly in stocks of companies across different sectors, sizes, and styles. Equity funds offer high returns potential but also carry high risk.
• Debt funds: These funds invest mainly in fixed income securities, such as bonds, debentures, treasury bills, etc. Debt funds offer low to moderate returns with low to moderate risk.
• Hybrid funds: These funds invest in a mix of equity and debt securities, in varying proportions. Hybrid funds offer a balance of risk and return, depending on the asset allocation.
• Index funds: These funds invest in securities that mimic a specific market index, as explained earlier. Index funds offer low-cost, diversified, and transparent exposure to the market.
• Sector funds: These funds invest in stocks of companies belonging to a particular sector, such as banking, IT, pharma, etc. Sector funds offer high returns potential but also carry high sector-specific risk.
• Thematic funds: These funds invest in stocks of companies that are related to a particular theme, such as infrastructure, consumption, environment, etc. Thematic funds offer high returns potential but also carry high theme-specific risk.

Factors to consider before investing in mutual funds

Before investing in mutual funds, one should consider the following factors:

• Investment goal: Mutual funds offer various schemes to suit different investment goals, such as wealth creation, income generation, tax saving, etc. One should invest in mutual funds that match their investment goal and time horizon.
• Risk profile: Mutual funds offer different risk-return profiles, depending on the asset class, sector, style, etc. One should invest in mutual funds that match their risk profile and risk tolerance.
• Performance: Mutual funds require a comparison and evaluation of the performance of different schemes, based on parameters such as returns, risk, consistency, benchmark, peer group, etc. One should invest in mutual funds that have a proven track record of delivering superior and stable returns over the long term.
• Cost: Mutual funds involve a cost in the form of expense ratio, which is deducted from the NAV of the scheme. One should invest in mutual funds that have a low expense ratio and do not compromise on the quality and performance of the scheme.

Factors to consider before investing in PMS

Before investing in PMS, one should consider the following factors:

• Risk appetite: PMS involves higher risk than mutual funds, as the portfolio manager can take aggressive bets on the securities and sectors. One should invest in PMS only if they have a high risk appetite and can tolerate volatility in the portfolio value.
• Investment horizon: PMS requires a longer investment horizon than mutual funds, as the portfolio manager may take time to generate returns from the portfolio. One should invest in PMS only if they have a long-term investment horizon of at least 3-5 years.
• Cost: PMS involves higher cost than mutual funds, as the portfolio manager charges a fee for their services, which can be fixed, variable, or performance-based. One should invest in PMS only if they can afford the cost and are confident of the portfolio manager’s ability to deliver returns.
• Track record: PMS requires a thorough research and analysis of the portfolio manager’s track record, credentials, investment philosophy, and performance. One should invest in PMS only if they are satisfied with the portfolio manager’s reputation and results.

Should you invest in PMS as well as mutual funds?

Investing in Portfolio Management Services (PMS) and mutual funds offers distinct advantages and caters to different investor needs.

PMS is tailored for high-net-worth individuals seeking personalised investment strategies. It allows for a customised portfolio based on individual financial goals, risk tolerance, and preferences. Managed by experienced portfolio managers, PMS offers direct ownership of securities and the potential for higher returns, albeit with higher risks. The minimum investment is typically higher, making it less accessible to average investors.

Mutual funds, on the other hand, pool money from multiple investors to invest in diversified assets, managed by professional fund managers. They provide an affordable and convenient option for small to medium investors. With a variety of funds available, investors can choose based on their risk appetite and investment horizon. Mutual funds offer liquidity, diversification, and regulatory oversight, ensuring a lower risk compared to PMS. They are ideal for those seeking steady growth with moderate risk.

In conclusion, while PMS offers bespoke solutions and the potential for higher returns for affluent investors, mutual funds provide a balanced, accessible, and diversified investment option for the general public. Your choice should align with your financial goals, investment capacity, and risk tolerance.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Mutual Funds offer diversification, simplicity, and accessibility to a broad spectrum of investors, PMS provides customisation, transparency, and personalised portfolio management for High Net-worth Individuals (HNIs). Understanding the nuances between these two investment avenues, including their fee structures, risk profiles, and investment strategies, is imperative for making informed financial decisions.

Ultimately, the choice between Mutual Funds and PMS depends on individual investor preferences, risk tolerance, investment objectives, and portfolio size. By weighing these factors carefully, investors can optimise their investment portfolios to achieve their financial goals effectively.

Essential tools for all mutual fund investors