SARs provide a flexible, low-risk way to share company growth rewards without ownership complexities or upfront costs.
For employees:
- No upfront investment: With SARs, you can enjoy financial rewards linked to company growth without needing to invest your own money in purchasing shares.
- No ownership stress: You participate in the upside of the company’s performance without the complexities of owning or managing shares directly.
- Tax simplicity: You’re only taxed when the SARs are exercised, and the payout is received making the tax process much easier to manage than traditional stock options.
For employers:
- No share dilution: SARs allow you to reward employees without issuing additional shares, which helps maintain your company’s equity structure.
- Simple administration: Since there’s no transfer of stock ownership, managing SARs is less complex than handling ESOPs or stock options.
- Performance alignment: Employees become more invested in helping the company grow, knowing their potential reward is tied to the company’s success.
What is an ESOP and how do they work?
Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) provide employees with a real stake in the company through actual ownership of shares. Unlike SARs, where you’re rewarded based on the rise in share value, ESOPs give you tangible equity.
These shares may be allotted at a discounted rate or offered as a part of your overall compensation package. As you continue working with the company and vest more shares over time, your equity grows. When you retire or exit the company, you have the option to sell these shares and potentially realise a substantial profit.
In essence, ESOPs are not just a reward they're a strategic tool for building long-term wealth and fostering deep engagement.
Need liquidity without selling equity? Use ESOP financing to convert your stock-based rewards into cash.
Benefits of ESOPs compared to other employee benefit plans
ESOPs uniquely combine ownership, wealth creation, and employee motivation, offering advantages beyond traditional salary or bonus programs.
For employees:
- Actual ownership: With ESOPs, you're more than just an employee you become a shareholder with a real ownership stake in the business.
- Wealth over time: As the company grows and becomes more valuable, so does your shareholding. This makes ESOPs a strong tool for personal wealth creation.
- Tax benefits: Depending on the structure, ESOPs may offer tax advantages such as deferral of taxes until shares are sold, and possibly lower capital gains taxes.
- Loyalty incentive: Since ESOPs often vest over time, employees have an incentive to stay longer and contribute actively to company growth.
Know more about: ESOP vesting period
For employers:
- Higher retention: Employees who own a part of the company tend to be more committed, leading to lower attrition rates and better organisational stability.
- Shared mission: ESOPs transform employees into stakeholders creating a culture where everyone is working toward a common business goal.
- Attracts top talent: Offering equity ownership can be a powerful draw for skilled professionals looking for long-term value in their compensation packages.
Have unexercised ESOPs? Don’t wait for a liquidity event. Apply for ESOP Financing and access funds for your personal or professional needs without having to sell your shares prematurely.
Key differences between SARs and ESOPs
Not sure how Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs) stack up against Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs)? This quick comparison breaks down the key differences at a glance:
Feature
|
SARs
|
ESOPs
|
Ownership
|
No share ownership
|
Actual share ownership
|
Payout
|
Cash or shares based on appreciation
|
Sale of shares (owned by employee)
|
Upfront cost
|
None
|
Employee may pay discounted price for shares
|
Dilution
|
No dilution
|
Dilutes company stock
|
Taxation
|
Taxed as income when exercised
|
Taxed when shares are sold
|
Risk
|
Low (no market risk)
|
High (market-linked risk)
|
Vesting
|
Can be immediate or over time
|
Typically vested over multiple years
|
Liquidity
|
Often faster payout
|
May require waiting for sale event or buyback
|
Which one should you choose?
Here’s a quick decision guide based on your financial goals:
Goal
|
Better fit
|
Immediate financial gain
|
SARs
|
Long-term wealth creation
|
ESOPs
|
No risk, no upfront cost
|
SARs
|
Owning a part of the company
|
ESOPs
|
Avoiding stock dilution (company’s view)
|
SARs
|
Encouraging employee retention
|
ESOPs
|
What employers should consider (SAR vs ESOP)?
Choosing between Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs) and Employee Stock Option Plans (ESOPs) is not just about rewarding employees it’s about aligning incentives with your company’s stage, cash flows, and long-term goals. Here is what employers should evaluate before deciding:
Business stage and growth plans
- Early-stage or bootstrapped firms often prefer SARs as they avoid immediate equity dilution.
- Growth-stage or scaling companies may lean towards ESOPs to build long-term ownership culture and retention.
Dilution and ownership control
- SARs do not create actual share ownership, helping founders retain tighter control.
- ESOPs lead to equity dilution but foster a strong sense of ownership among employees.
Cash flow impact
- SARs usually require cash payouts at the time of exercise or settlement, which can strain liquidity.
- ESOPs are largely non-cash at grant, making them easier on short-term cash flows.
Employee motivation and retention
- ESOPs tend to create stronger emotional buy-in, as employees become shareholders.
- SARs work well for performance-linked incentives without long vesting complexities.
Valuation and administration complexity
- ESOPs involve formal valuations, cap table management, and regulatory compliance.
- SARs are simpler to administer and easier to communicate, especially in unlisted companies.
Exit strategy and liquidity events
- If you anticipate an IPO or acquisition, ESOPs integrate more naturally into exit outcomes.
- SARs are better suited when exits are uncertain or when companies want payout flexibility.
What should employees consider?
Your choice between SARs and ESOPs can shape your financial outcomes, tax exposure, and access to liquidity.
- Growth potential: If your company is on a high-growth trajectory, ESOPs can help you build significant long-term wealth by giving you actual ownership in the business. The more the company scales, the more your shares are worth. SARs, on the other hand, give you a share in the upside without the responsibility of ownership. The returns may be capped, but so is the risk.
- Tax planning: Each equity plan follows a different tax structure. SARs are usually taxed as ordinary income upon exercise, whereas ESOPs may qualify for capital gains tax when shares are sold. Aligning your plan with your tax strategy is crucial. Know how ESOP taxation works to optimise your returns.
- Access to cash: SARs often result in quicker payouts once exercised, offering immediate financial benefit. ESOPs usually require a liquidity event—such as an IPO, acquisition, or company buyback which may take years. This difference can be crucial if you have pressing financial goals.
What should employers consider?
Choosing between SARs and ESOPs affects your company’s finances, retention strategy, and overall equity management approach.
- Cash vs. equity trade-off: SARs don’t dilute company equity but may result in significant cash outflows when exercised. ESOPs, in contrast, involve issuing new shares or redistributing existing ones, which dilutes ownership but preserves cash. The right choice depends on your company’s current financial health and long-term cap table strategy.
- Employee tenure: If your goal is to retain top talent and build long-term loyalty, ESOPs are often more effective. They make employees stakeholders, not just workers, and give them a direct reason to stay and contribute to company growth. SARs may appeal to shorter-term contributors who value immediate rewards over long-term equity.
- Administrative simplicity: SARs are typically easier to administer. There's no need to manage shareholding accounts or navigate complex securities laws. ESOPs require a more involved setup and ongoing compliance, which might increase your legal and administrative burden.
Read about: ESOP vs Equity
Final thoughts
Both SARs and ESOPs are powerful tools—but they serve different purposes. SARs reward short-term performance without equity dilution. ESOPs build long-term ownership and engagement. The right choice depends on your goals as an employee looking to grow your wealth, or as a business designing the right compensation structure.
Got ESOPs waiting to be exercised? Don’t let them sit idle.
Use ESOP Financing to access liquidity today without selling your shares.
